A Threat, Not a Theory

“A Threat, Not a Theory”

Nick Hanauer in Democracy Journal critically examines the long-standing claim that raising the minimum wage inevitably leads to job losses and economic harm. The article argues that this belief is less a proven economic theory and more a rhetorical tactic employed by opponents of wage increases.

Main Points:

• Challenging Economic Orthodoxy: The article notes that critics of minimum wage hikes routinely assert, as if it were a law of nature, that higher wages must reduce employment. This “theory” is widely repeated in media and policy debates, but the author points out that it has not held up in practice.

• Empirical Evidence: The federal minimum wage has been raised 22 times since 1938, and state and local minimum wages have increased hundreds of times. Despite frequent predictions of job losses, there is little empirical evidence that these increases have led to widespread unemployment or economic decline. In fact, a 2014 letter signed by over 600 economists, including Nobel laureates, concluded that minimum wage increases have had “little or no negative effect on the employment of minimum-wage workers, even during times of weakness in the labor market”.

• Not a Scientific Theory: The article argues that, unlike scientific theories that consistently predict outcomes (such as Newton’s laws), the supposed inverse relationship between wages and employment is not consistently borne out by data. Any effects—positive or negative—are so small they are lost in the broader churn of the economy.

• Trickle-Down Economics Critique: The author contends that the real power of the “job killer” argument is not economic but political: it serves as a tool for the powerful to resist wage increases for the less powerful. The threat that higher wages will destroy jobs is characterized as a scare tactic rooted in trickle-down economics, designed to maintain low wages and suppress worker bargaining power.

• The Real Threat: The piece concludes that the true danger for opponents of a $15 minimum wage is not that it will harm the economy, but that it will help workers and expose the flaws in trickle-down arguments. Raising the minimum wage, the author asserts, would lift millions out of poverty and reveal that decades of wage suppression were justified by a “scam”—not sound economics.

Conclusion

The article dismisses the claim that minimum wage hikes are inherently job-killing as a “threat, not a theory,” arguing that history and data show little evidence for the dire consequences often predicted. Instead, it frames opposition to higher wages as a political strategy rather than a conclusion based on economic science.

Nick Hanauer, “A Threat, Not a Theory,” Democracy Journal.

https://democracyjournal.org/magazine/41/a-threat-not-a-theory/

 

Prosper Georgetown is a 501(c) 3 non-profit organization certified under File Number 803442241
by the Office of the Secretary of State for the State of Texas, dated 10/10/2019.